COMPARE
Agencies.co vs GoMerge: Agency M&A Compared
Choosing the right M&A advisor for your agency exit is one of the most important decisions you will make as a founder. Both Agencies.co and Merge (GoMerge.com) offer agency-focused M&A services, but they differ significantly in pricing structure, incentive alignment, and approach. This comparison gives you an honest, numbers-driven breakdown — including where Merge has genuine strengths and where the model falls short.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Agencies.co | Merge (GoMerge.com) |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Marketplace + M&A advisory (tiered) | Traditional M&A brokerage |
| Focus | Marketing & communications agencies only | Originally agencies — now also ecommerce, retail, media, tech |
| Retainer | Capped ceiling: $12,000 total (Standard) / $30,000 total (Boardroom) | Uncapped: $5,000 – $20,000 per month, ongoing |
| Success Fee | 10% of cash at close | 10% of cash at close |
| Close Rate | ~10% (industry standard for agency M&A) | ~10% implied (100 closed / 1,000 “guided”) |
| Self-Serve Option | Yes — Lite tier at $2,500 | No — minimum engagement is $5K/month retainer |
| Deal Size | $500K – $30M+ | Under $50M |
| Technology Layer | AI valuation tool, automated buyer matching, digital CIM | Purely human-driven — no technology tools |
| Timeline | Incentivised to close within 6 months (retainer capped) | 4–6 months typical, but retainer continues indefinitely |
About Agencies.co
Agencies.co is a marketplace and advisory platform built exclusively for marketing agency M&A. The platform offers three tiers designed to match different seller needs: Lite ($2,500) for self-managed listings with marketplace exposure, Standard ($12,000 capped retainer) for a professional setup sprint with valuation, CIM, bespoke buyer list, and targeted outreach, and Boardroom ($30,000 capped) for full white-glove advisory over 6 months with a senior advisor on calls and pre-LOI negotiation support. With retainer ceilings that protect sellers from escalating costs and a success fee model that aligns incentives, Agencies.co combines technology-driven efficiency with hands-on M&A expertise.
About Merge (GoMerge.com)
Merge is a traditional M&A advisory firm founded around 2015, originally focused on marketing agency transactions. Over the past decade, they have expanded into ecommerce, retail, media, and technology services — though they are still mainly known in the agency space. They operate a 9-step advisory process from initial consultation through closing and transition, with monthly retainers ranging from $5,000 to $20,000 and a 10% success fee. The firm claims to have “guided” over 1,000 businesses, with approximately 100 completed transactions showcased in their portfolio. Merge has built a strong founder-led brand with an active LinkedIn presence and a referral programme.
Where Merge Has Genuine Strengths
We believe in honest comparisons. These are real strengths:
- Longevity — roughly 10 years of experience in agency M&A
- Case study portfolio — approximately 100 completed transactions
- Full-service process — end-to-end from valuation through post-close transition
- Strong founder-led brand with active LinkedIn presence
- Human capital valuation expertise — understanding the people side of agency deals
- Referral programme with incentives for introductions
The Uncapped Retainer Problem
This is the most important difference between Agencies.co and Merge, and it comes down to one word: alignment.
Merge charges a monthly retainer of $5,000 to $20,000 — and that retainer continues for as long as the engagement runs. There is no ceiling. The longer your deal takes, the more Merge earns in retainer fees. This creates a structural misalignment: Merge’s revenue increases the longer the process drags out.
Agencies.co’s retainer is capped. The Standard tier is $12,000 total — that is the ceiling, regardless of how long the engagement takes. The Boardroom tier caps at $30,000. Once you hit the ceiling, there is no more retainer billing. The team is incentivised to close within 6 months because there is no additional retainer revenue to collect after the cap.
What This Costs You in Practice
| Scenario | Merge Cost (Retainer Only) | Agencies.co Cost (Retainer Only) | You Save |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4-month close at $10K/month | $40,000 | $12,000 (Standard) | $28,000 |
| 5-month close at $10K/month | $50,000 | $12,000 (Standard) | $38,000 |
| 6-month close at $15K/month | $90,000 | $12,000 (Standard) | $78,000 |
| 8-month close at $15K/month | $120,000 | $12,000 (Standard) | $108,000 |
Both platforms charge a 10% success fee on cash at close, so the retainer difference is pure savings. On a deal that takes 6 months at $15K/month with Merge, you would save $78,000 with Agencies.co’s Standard tier — before the deal even closes.
The Real Question: What Does It Cost When the Deal Does Not Close?
Agency M&A is hard. Roughly 1 in 10 engaged sellers close a transaction — that is the industry reality, not a marketing number. Both Agencies.co and Merge operate in this same environment. The difference is not who claims a higher close rate — it is what the process costs you when the deal does not work out.
Merge claims to have “guided” over 1,000 businesses. Their portfolio showcases approximately 100 completed transactions — roughly a 10% conversion rate, which is consistent with the broader agency M&A industry. That is not a criticism — it is the reality of the market.
The question is: what did the other 900 pay? With Merge’s uncapped monthly retainer at $5,000 to $20,000 per month, a seller who engaged for 6 months at $10K/month and did not close paid $60,000 in retainers with nothing to show for it. With Agencies.co’s Standard tier, the maximum retainer exposure is $12,000 — regardless of how long the engagement lasts or whether the deal closes.
When you are paying $5,000 to $20,000 per month on an uncapped retainer, the cost of failure is the most important number you can calculate. If the deal does not close — and statistically, most do not — you want to have paid $12,000 for the attempt, not $60,000 or $120,000.
Scope Creep: Still Agency-Focused?
Merge originally built its reputation in marketing agency M&A. But they have since expanded into ecommerce, retail, media, and technology services. This expansion is understandable from a business perspective — agency M&A alone may not sustain a monthly retainer model at their price point — but it means their team’s attention, expertise, and buyer network are now divided across multiple verticals.
Agencies.co remains 100% focused on marketing and communications agencies. Every valuation model, every buyer relationship, and every team member’s expertise is directed at one sector. Specialisation matters in M&A, and dilution of focus inevitably dilutes quality.
A Note on Reputation
Merge has a reputation in the agency community for initiating engagements with founders who may not be fully ready to sell. Their monthly retainer model creates an incentive to start as many engagements as possible — each new retainer generates immediate revenue regardless of whether the deal ultimately closes. This is a common complaint in agency owner circles and worth investigating before signing an engagement letter.
Agencies.co’s capped retainer model removes this incentive. There is no benefit to starting an engagement that is unlikely to close, because the retainer revenue is limited regardless of timeline.
Technology vs. Purely Human
Merge operates a purely human-driven process — which has value, but also limitations in speed, consistency, and reach. There are no technology tools for valuation, buyer matching, or deal management.
Agencies.co combines human M&A expertise with technology: an AI-powered valuation tool that gives founders an instant, agency-specific assessment; automated buyer matching based on sector, size, and deal criteria; and a digital platform for managing the entire deal lifecycle. Technology does not replace human judgment in M&A — but it accelerates the parts that should be fast, so advisors can focus on the parts that require expertise.
Who Should Use Merge
Merge may be a reasonable choice if you have already worked with them and trust the relationship; your deal is complex enough to justify $5K–$20K/month in ongoing retainer fees; you are confident the deal will close quickly (under 4 months) to limit retainer exposure; you do not need a self-serve option and are comfortable with a fully managed process; or you are selling a non-agency business in one of their expanded verticals (ecommerce, retail, media, tech).
Who Should Use Agencies.co
Agencies.co is the right choice if you are selling a marketing, creative, PR, digital, or communications agency; you want a capped retainer that protects you from escalating costs; incentive alignment matters to you — you want your advisor incentivised to close, not to bill; you want to limit your downside when the deal does not close — $12,000 maximum exposure vs. potentially $60,000–$120,000; you value technology-assisted efficiency alongside human advisory; you want a self-serve option (Lite at $2,500) if your agency is smaller or you prefer to manage the process yourself; or you want an advisor who is 100% focused on agencies — not splitting attention across ecommerce, retail, and tech.
The Verdict
Merge is an established player in agency M&A with a decade of experience and a portfolio of completed transactions. That longevity has value, and we respect what they have built.
But the structural differences matter. An uncapped monthly retainer that can reach $120,000 over an 8-month engagement creates a fundamental misalignment between advisor and seller. Expanding beyond agencies into ecommerce, retail, media, and tech means the specialisation that once defined Merge is no longer as sharp. And when roughly 9 in 10 deals do not close — which is the industry reality — the cost of that failed engagement is what separates the two models.
Agencies.co offers capped retainers ($12,000 Standard / $30,000 Boardroom), 100% agency focus, technology-assisted efficiency, and a model designed to align your advisor’s incentives with your outcome. Selling an agency is hard — roughly 1 in 10 deals close. That is why how you pay matters. $12K capped retainer, not $10K/month forever.
Ready to Get Started?
The best next step is always the same: understand what your agency is actually worth. Our free AI-powered valuation gives you an honest, agency-specific assessment in minutes — no obligation, no sales pitch.
Get a Free Valuation | Sell Your Agency | Browse Listings | Schedule a Call